I have owne a number of plastic water bottles over the years, including multiple from contigo.
And while I was happy with them, they were in no way perfect. So in the end of 2018 I decided to order a tripple walled bottle from 24 Bottles. I got the "climate" bottle, it has two layers of insulation keep cold water cold for 24 hours and hot stuff hot for 12. I went with a black one with the largest capacity available. My only regret is that I did not get one without paint on it. Becase it isn't the kind of finish that look cool as it's worn down.
I love this bottle, I can fill it with ice after dinner and still have some left when I get home from work. This is the kind of bottle I don't see myself having to replace in a very long time. You could probably drive a car over it and still use it after.
The default lid is very old school and sturdy, but you have to screw and unscrew it. It is what I have used since I got mine close to a year ago.
But I have ordered one of the new sport lids that is more like regular water bottles where you don't have to unscrew it. I strongly recommend getting one from 24 Bottles.
What I like about it is that unlike the plastic bottles the water never gets hot.This was a huge issue when I used a plastic bottle in the office.